Cogan Pill House

Hemmed in by a busy junction and overshadowed by an abundance of modern houses and apartments, Cogan Pill House, a Tudor period mansion also known as 'The Baron's Court', seems somewhat out of place in our hectic modern world.  Crooked and aged, Cogan Pill House is a mass of mullioned windows and protruding chimney stacks; a veritable historical Gem, and although heavily remodelled during the middle of the nineteenth century, Cogan Pill House has a long history dating back to the late medieval period giving it the distinction of being by far the oldest standing building in the Penarth area.

(Cogan Pill House when it was sill a private residence taken during the early 1960's. RCAHMW)

The earliest written reference to this grey and ancient gentry house comes from the will of Mathew Craddock of Swansea who died in 1533.  John Leland in the late 1530s mentions Cogan Pill House in his Itinerary in Wales recording that "Cogan march Pille wher is a fair maner place on the ripe side longging to Mr. Herbert of Swansey". Glamorgan antiquarian Rice Merrick (Rhys Meurug) lists Cogan Pill House in his 1578 publication, A Book of Glamorganshire's Antiquities, as a 'castle bordering near the sea coast'.

The ancient medieval manor of Cogan, once rated at two knights' fees, was purchased by George Herbert (1494/1570) of Swansea from king Henry VIII in 1544. The Herbert family of Cogan were related to a vast family network who held land and manors across south Wales and beyond. The Herbert family were also related to the earl of Pembroke and as a result seemingly benefited from his patronage, often holding high offices within Glamorganshire and at court.

                           (William Herbert Earl of Pembroke 1501-1570. Museum of Wales)

George Herbert was a busy man and actively engaged in political affairs of both local and national importance. George helped to set up the Act of Union in 1536 and also fought for Henry VIII in France at Boulogne in the 1540s. George Herbert became Glamorgan's first sheriff in 1540/1, Glamorgan's first knight in parliament and mayor of Cardiff in 1553. 

It seemed however that George Herbert had rivals. One such man was Sir Rhys Mansell of Oxwich, and later Margam, whose position of Chamberlin of South Wales was jealously sought by Herbert.  Acting on a tip-off, the exchequer in 1555 ordered George Herbert to reduce his personal retinue to a maximum of forty men. It is possible that it was Sir Rhys who informed the exchequer, becoming alarmed at the considerable number of men at George's disposal and their potential to cause trouble. These concerns were not unwarranted as it was a fact that George Herbert had a capacity for violence. For example in 1538 George was accused of assaulting two of Sir Edward Carne's sons at Cowbridge and was brought before the Star Chamber in London as a result.

                      (Oxwich castle, the home of George Herbert's rival Rhys Mansell)

The Herbert and Mansell clans eventually came to blows at Oxwich in 1557 over the fate of a floundered French vessel.  In the melee which followed, Mansell's sister,  Anne Mansell was accidentally killed. This led to the arrest of George Herbert, a relative of George named William Herbert and eighteen other people, many of whom were from Swansea, and their subsequent trial for manslaughter. All pleaded pardon and allowance. The outcome of the trial however in not known. Upon George's death in 1570 he was badly in debt to the Crown owing over £1000, a terrific sum of money in the sixteenth century. George's inability to pay off his debt saw the Crown seize his property for a total of two years. 

George Herbert's son and heir William Herbert (1532-1576) is believed to have been responsible for the enlargement of Cogan Pill House resulting in the form that we see today. William Herbert, like his father, was also active in politics and held the office of Sheriff of Glamorgan in 1552 and again in 1567.

In 1557/8 William Herbert was accused by Sir Thomas Stradling of St Donats of extorting money from five of his servants and the local population at large by issuing a tax: 'For his own private lucre and gain of his own authority and to extort power by colour of furniture of harness'.  This tax was ostensibly to help fund Herbert, who was commissioned by his uncle the earl of Pembroke, also called William Herbert, on a military campaign in France in 1557 where he was to command one hundred men, but in reality it was to line his own pockets. Apparently the tax was scrupulously enforced with neither "widow nor orphan being spared" making William Herbert very unpopular and earning him the nickname 'Black Will'. This was a serious matter which was brought to the Star Chamber in London, and although Herbert did his best to avoid being present at his indictment, he was eventually apprehended by the Sheriff of Glamorgan, William Bassett. The case against Herbert however eventually lapsed upon the death of Queen Mary in 1558.

Another unscrupulous member of the Herbert clan of Cogan Pill was one Nicholas Herbert (1543-1601). Nicholas like his predecessors held the office of sheriff of Glamorgan on numerous occasions, and it seems was similarly covetous. Nicholas was in 1577 fined £200 for colluding with pirates.

During the early seventeenth century yet another William Herbert of Cogan Pill found himself embroiled in controversy. William was indicted in the Court of Chivalry in 1637 for giving one John Matthew of Llandaff 'scandalous words provocative of a duel'. Quarreling, feuds and violence as we have seen were common amongst the Glamorgan gentry during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, often resulting in mass brawls, serious injury and even death. For example, a relation of William, one John Herbert (1540-1617) of Neath died a violent death in Cardiff as the result of a duel fought against Sir Lewis Tresham in 1617; his tomb can be seen inside St John's Church, Cardiff. The outcome of this particular quarrel however is not known although it's likely that violence on this occasion was averted.

During the middle of the seventeenth century Lt Colonel William Herbert of Cogan Pill, who was a prominent Royalist during the English Civil War, met his end at the battle of Edge-Hill in 1642 fighting with a Glamorgan contingent alongside Sir Edward Stradling of St Donats, who himself commanded a regiment of foot. Sir Edward survived and was taken prisoner after the battle.

Upon the death of Colonel Herbert a relation and fellow Royalist who resided at Grey Friars in Cardiff-also called William Herbert, received wardship of Cogan Pill. In the same year this particular William Herbert handed over Cardiff Castle to Royalist forces and gave the earl of Pembroke's revenues from his estates in south Wales, which he was entrusted to manage on the earl's behalf, to king Charles I. This controversial act earned himself the appellation of "ungrateful kinsman" from the earl who was himself a staunch Parliamentarian. This particular William Herbert died in 1645. The wardship of Cogan Pill was taken over by his wife Anne Herbert, who in turn died in around 1650 leaving Cogan Pill to her nephew William Morgan of Pencrug in Monmouthshire. 

(Herbert House/Grey Friars Cardiff, a possession of the Herbert family and the home to William Herbert who from 1642-5 held the wardship of  Cogan Pill, pictured not long before its demolition in the 1960's. RCAHMW)

The history of Herbert family of Cogan Pill from this time on appears unremarkable. They seemingly led a quiet existance and continued to occupy Cogan Pill House throughout the latter part of the seventeenth century as well as the majority of the eighteenth century as their wills attest to. The Glamorgan hearth tax of 1670 lists one Edward Harbert as occupant of Cogan Pill. Edawrd was liable to pay a tax of sixteen shilling for the use of eight hearths. By the time of the eighteenth century however many the great Tudor gentry houses of Glamorgan were seen to be architecturally outdated and uncomfortable. Cogan Pill House by the late eighteenth century was rented out as a farmhouse. 

     (Painting of Cogan Pill house dating from 1850. National Library of Wales)

In 1793 the house and manor of Cogan was purchased by the earl of Bute who continued to rent Cogan Pill as a farmhouse. By the early nineteenth century the great hall which once lay at the heart of the Herbert household and enterprise was in use of a barn to house cattle. Cogan Pill continued to be a farmhouse until the middle of the nineteenth century when it was renovated and converted into a comfortable residence for a relative of the Marquis of Bute, the estate agent and architect Mr H S Corbett.  The interior of the main hall was given a makeover in a quasi-medieval style complete with multi-coloured brick walls and gothic arch inserted adjacent to the grand fireplace. The castellated parapets were also added at this time.

(Some of Mr H S Corbett's mid nineteenth century alterations. RCAHMW)

Cogan Pill House continued to be a private residence until the middle of the twentieth century when it became a pub/disco followed by a carvery restaurant. By this time it was sadly gutted of most of its ancient interior. The building however can still very much be appreciated as a historical gem, and constitutes a valuable local historical asset. 

(View of Cogan Pill house porch with the Herbert Coat of arms surmounted above the entrance. RCAHMW)

Mark and Jonathan Lambert are writers based in the Vale of Glamorgan. They are both archaeology graduates of Cardiff University and have written a number of books. They have been writing about and researching local history for the past 20 years. All articles are original compositions - we hope you enjoy our content. 

Enquiries: hiddenglamorgan@outlook.com

©Jonathan and Mark Lambert 2018

The right of Jonathan and Mark Lambert to be identified as Authors of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyrights, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reprinted, reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic means, including social media, or mechanical, or by any other means including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the authors.